Cheese · Cheesemaking

If It Looks Like Cheddar…

YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYY!

IMG_1624_1

Ahem.

So, I knew I could sample the Farmhouse Cheddar as early as a month after waxing. 

Originally I was going to try to hold off for two months, but…I was just so curious.  A mix of curious and worried that maybe I'd somehow messed something up and it would be spoiled. 

I just had to know. 

So earlier in the week I decided that we'd sample the Farmhouse on Friday. 

Then I sort of forgot about it because I got 2 gallons of goat milk at the Farmers' Market yesterday and got distracted by thoughts of chevre.  Mmmmmmmm…chevre….

So when Bill said something like "Are you still doing the cheese tonight?" I thought he meant was I going to make the chevre…and then I remembered. 

The cheddar!

So I got it out of my temperature-regulated chest freezer "cave" and brought it out to the deck on a plate with a knife and some crackers.

IMG_1589

And with little fanfare (just some pictures), I picked off the label and cut the wheel in half.

IMG_1590 

And pulled the halves apart.

IMG_1591 
AND THERE WAS NO SLIME OR MOLD OR ANYTHING BAD!

IMG_1592_1 
Sorry, I'm still a bit dazzled by it all.

I cut one half in two and peeled the wax off, and took pictures (while Bill fidgeted impatiently nearby) and finally, finally, we sampled a slice.

IMG_1594
IMG_1595
IMG_1596_1 
And…

…it tasted…

…like…

…mild cheddar cheese.

Holy dairy cow, Batman!

I did it!!!!!!

But actually, the REAL test was still to come.  I've said, more than once, that Alex doesn't like soft cheeses, so he hasn't liked any of the ricotta, mozzarella, chevre, or cream cheese I've made in the past.  So in addition to just the natural progression of things, part of the reason I've wanted to make hard cheeses was so I could make something Alex could enjoy.

So I hollered into the house and summoned the kids.

And we gave Alex a slice of cheddar on a cracker…

IMG_1601
And, after careful chewing and consideration…

IMG_1604
He gave his stamp of approval…

IMG_1600 
And had another bite.

And I breathed a sigh of relief.

IMG_1619

If you missed the earlier posts on the making of this cheddar, you can read them here and here

12 thoughts on “If It Looks Like Cheddar…

  1. Cheese, glorious cheese– so scrumptious and luscious…

    Congratulations, Jayne. I wouldn’t mind a slice of that myself.

  2. Beautiful cheese! You’re making me want to make some. Especially once I read “chevre”. Mmmmm. Can’t wait to see your chevre.

  3. Yes! My other two cheddars (so far) will age for longer periods of time, and in fact I might cut them both in half, re-dry half of each and wax them again so we can sample at different stages.

Leave a Reply